Which puzzles have prize cards?

• Keys To Philly (1–∞, rare)

  • illustrated by David Loebman

  • October keys have alternate art, an alternate color frame, and are extra rare

• The Philly Treasure Hunt (1A, 1B, uncommon)

  • cards for The Philly Treasure Hunt 2024 have not been printed yet; if you participated and would like one, please DM me

• The Rittenhouse Riddle (2A, uncommon)

• Trail Treasures (3A, rare)

  • illustrated by David Loebman

• The Winter Challenge (4A–4E, uncommon)

• Unlock 250 (5A–5L, extra rare)

• Marsha Madness (6A, common)

• coming soon: Quest for the Relic

• more to come…

How do you choose the colors?

I basically choose the colors based on vibe. Is the puzzle focused on a park? Then the card is green.

How does rarity work?

The rarity listed at the bottom of the cards is based on a combination of how hard the card is to earn and how many of them exist.

How does the numbering work?

Keys To Philly cards only have numbers, which correspond to the numbering of the keys. They get to be special because they were the first type of card I created, and Keys To Philly is my most popular and longest-running series.

All other cards have a number and a letter. The numbers represent when, sequentially, I created the first card for that project. The letters represent which iteration of that puzzle project the card corresponds to. For example, the first card I created (after launching the prize cards with Keys To Philly) was for The Philly Treasure Hunt 2025, which was the second Philly Treasure Hunt. Thus, Philly Treasure Hunt 2025 cards are numbered 1B, and cards for the next one will be numbered 1C. Next, I created a card for The Rittenhouse Riddle, which will not have additional iterations, so those cards are numbered 2A.

Will you create cards for puzzles that are no longer active?

When I can! It’s hard to get cards to participants retroactively, but sometimes I just have to. The Winter Challenge is one example, because it’s dear to my heart and because people ask me if I’m going to make another one every year. So I’ve created this form to try and get cards to as many people who competed in Winter Challenges before I started making prize cards as possible. I don’t currently plan on creating retroactive prize cards for South Philly Mural Escape or Philly Spycraft Mission, but I do plan to make cards for future bookable experiences, like Quest for the Relic.